The moments following an accident can be overwhelming. Your mind races, adrenaline pumps through your body, and you’re suddenly faced with countless decisions—including what to say to insurance companies. One wrong statement could potentially cost you thousands in compensation and jeopardize your recovery. When it comes to dealing with insurance adjusters, the less said, the better isn’t just a cliché—it’s essential legal wisdom that could protect your rights and financial future.
Insurance companies aren’t in business to hand out maximum settlements. They’re profit-driven entities with teams of adjusters trained to minimize payouts and protect their bottom line. Understanding what not to say can be the difference between receiving the compensation you deserve and settling for far less than your case is worth.
Why Your Words Matter More Than You Think
Every year in California, thousands of accident victims unintentionally damage their claims by speaking too freely with insurance representatives. These seemingly innocent conversations can become powerful evidence against you later in your case.
Insurance adjusters are professionals at getting you to say things that can be used to reduce or deny your claim. They may sound friendly and concerned, but remember—their loyalty is to their employer, not to you.
The Recording Is Always Running
When speaking with an insurance company:
- Every call is typically recorded
- Your statements become part of your permanent claim file
- Words taken out of context can be misrepresented later
- Even innocent comments can be twisted to imply fault or minimize injuries
The Critical First 24-48 Hours: What To Do Instead of Talking
Your actions immediately following an accident set the foundation for your entire claim. Before engaging with any insurance company, prioritize these critical steps:
1. Seek Medical Attention Immediately
Even if you feel “fine” after an accident, some injuries aren’t immediately apparent. Whiplash, internal injuries, and traumatic brain injuries can take hours or days to manifest symptoms.
Immediate medical care provides:
- Documentation of your injuries from day one
- A professional medical assessment before adrenaline wears off
- Evidence connecting your injuries directly to the accident
- Protection against claims that you “waited too long” to seek treatment
A same-day medical evaluation creates an irrefutable timeline that directly links your injuries to the accident—making it much harder for insurance companies to claim your injuries came from something else.
2. Document Everything
While details are fresh in your mind:
- Take photos of all vehicles involved, showing damage from multiple angles
- Photograph the accident scene, including skid marks, traffic signals, and road conditions
- Get contact information from witnesses
- Request a copy of the police report
- Keep all medical records, prescriptions, and receipts
- Start a daily journal documenting your pain levels and limitations
These records provide objective evidence that speaks louder than any statement you could make to an insurance adjuster.
3. Report the Accident—But Keep It Brief
You do need to notify your insurance company that an accident occurred—typically within 24-48 hours. However, this initial report should be brief and factual:
DO provide:
- Date, time, and location of the accident
- Names and contact information of other involved parties
- Your policy number
- The fact that an accident occurred
DON’T provide:
- Detailed descriptions of how the accident happened
- Speculation about fault
- Information about your injuries
- Recorded statements (without legal counsel)
Simply state, “I was involved in an accident on [date] at [location]. I’m still gathering information and receiving medical care. I’ll provide more details when I have them.
7 Things You Should Never Say to an Insurance Company
Now let’s examine the specific statements that can seriously damage your claim:
1. “I’m Sorry” or Any Admission of Fault
After an accident, many Californians instinctively apologize—even when they’ve done nothing wrong. This natural politeness can be catastrophic for your claim.
Why it’s dangerous: Any statement that could be interpreted as accepting responsibility can be used to:
- Shift liability to you (even partially)
- Reduce your compensation significantly
- Potentially void certain coverage protections
What to say instead: Stick strictly to the verifiable facts of what happened without assigning blame—to yourself or others. For example: “The accident occurred at the intersection of Wilshire and La Brea at approximately 2:30 PM.”
Even if you believe you may have contributed to the accident, fault determination is complex and involves many factors you may not be aware of. The other driver might have been texting, speeding, or impaired. Road conditions, signage, or vehicle defects could have played a role. Let the investigation reveal the full picture.
2. “I Feel Fine” or Downplaying Injuries
Many injuries from car accidents—particularly soft tissue injuries, concussions, and herniated discs—can take days or even weeks to fully manifest. Adrenaline can mask pain immediately after an accident.
Why it’s dangerous: If you tell an insurance adjuster you’re “feeling okay” or “not badly hurt” and later develop significant symptoms, the insurance company will use your own words to argue:
- Your injuries aren’t related to the accident
- You’re exaggerating your condition
- You lack credibility about your current symptoms
What to say instead: “I’m currently seeking medical evaluation to determine the full extent of any injuries.” Then, follow through with comprehensive medical assessment—even if you only feel “a little sore.”
Studies show that approximately 40% of car accident victims who initially report minor or no symptoms develop significant pain within 7-14 days. Protect your right to compensation for late-appearing injuries by never minimizing your condition.
3. “I Accept” or Discussing Settlement Amounts
Insurance companies often make quick, lowball settlement offers before you understand the full extent of your injuries and damages.
Why it’s dangerous: Once you accept a settlement offer:
- You typically waive your right to seek additional compensation
- Future medical complications won’t be covered
- Lost wages and long-term impacts aren’t factored in
- You may receive pennies on the dollar compared to what your claim is truly worth
What to say instead: “I cannot discuss settlement until I’ve completed my medical treatment and fully understand my prognosis.” Better yet: “Please direct all settlement discussions to my attorney.”
Early settlement offers rarely account for the true value of your claim. In California, the average initial settlement offer is typically 30-40% of what victims ultimately receive with proper legal representation.
4. “I Think…” or Any Speculation
Insurance adjusters excel at getting accident victims to guess, estimate, or hypothesize about what happened.
Why it’s dangerous: Speculative statements can:
- Create inconsistencies in your account
- Be used to question your memory or perception
- Become “admissions” that damage your position
- Provide ammunition for denying your claim
What to say instead: If you don’t know something with certainty, simply state: “I don’t have that information” or “I would need to review my records to answer that accurately.”
It’s perfectly acceptable—and legally prudent—to say “I don’t know” or “I don’t recall” when asked detailed questions about speeds, distances, timing, or other specifics that you aren’t 100% certain about.
5. “I Was Texting,” “I Was Tired,” or Admitting Distractions
Even seemingly minor admissions about your state of mind or activities before the accident can severely impact your claim.
Why it’s dangerous: Statements about being distracted, fatigued, or engaged with devices can:
- Be used to argue you were negligent
- Significantly reduce your compensation even if the other driver was primarily at fault
- Potentially trigger exclusions in your policy
What to say instead: Simply describe the mechanical facts of your driving: “I was traveling northbound on Main Street when the collision occurred.” Let investigators determine if distraction played a role.
California’s comparative negligence laws mean that your compensation can be reduced by the percentage of fault assigned to you. Even a casual comment like “I only glanced down for a second” can be used to attribute significant fault to you.
6. “You Can Access All My Medical Records”
Insurance companies often request blanket authorizations to access your entire medical history—far beyond what’s relevant to your current accident.
Why it’s dangerous: Providing unrestricted medical access allows insurers to:
- Look for pre-existing conditions to blame for your current symptoms
- Find unrelated health issues to question your credibility
- Invade your privacy regarding sensitive health matters
- Build a case against the causation element of your claim
What to say instead: “I’ll provide medical records specifically related to injuries from this accident after consulting with my attorney.”
Your medical privacy is protected by law. You can provide documentation of accident-related injuries without opening your entire health history to scrutiny.
7. “My Lawyer Told Me to Say…” or Discussing Legal Strategy
Revealing conversations with your attorney or your legal strategy can waive attorney-client privilege and undermine your position.
Why it’s dangerous: Mentioning your attorney’s advice:
- Potentially waives confidentiality protections
- Signals to adjusters that you have concerns about your case
- Can be twisted to make you appear untrustworthy or coached
What to say instead: Keep any legal advice you’ve received completely confidential. If asked about your attorney’s counsel, simply state: “Any discussions with my attorney are privileged.”
The Insurance Company's Playbook: Tactics to Watch For
Understanding the strategies insurance adjusters use can help you avoid their traps. Be alert for these common tactics:
The “Friendly” Adjuster Approach
Some adjusters present themselves as helpful allies who “just need a few details” to process your claim quickly.
The reality: Their friendliness is strategic—designed to lower your guard and encourage unfiltered conversation that could harm your claim.
How to respond: Remain polite but guarded. Provide only basic information and defer detailed discussions until you’ve consulted with an attorney.
The Rushed Settlement Pressure
Adjusters may emphasize the benefits of settling quickly—often before you know the full extent of your injuries.
The reality: Quick settlements almost always favor the insurance company, not you. Once you settle, you can’t reopen your claim, even if your injuries worsen.
How to respond: “I appreciate your offer, but I need to complete my medical treatment before considering any settlement.” Then contact a personal injury attorney immediately.
The Recorded Statement Request
Insurance companies frequently insist they need your recorded statement to “move forward” with your claim.
The reality: These recordings become powerful tools to find inconsistencies and limit your compensation.
How to respond: “I’m not comfortable providing a recorded statement at this time. I’ll be happy to provide necessary information in writing after speaking with my attorney.”
When to Involve a Personal Injury Attorney
While minor fender-benders sometimes can be handled directly with insurance companies, most significant accidents warrant legal representation. Consider contacting an attorney immediately if:
- You’ve suffered any significant injury requiring medical treatment
- The accident involved multiple vehicles or parties
- Fault is disputed or unclear
- The accident occurred in a construction zone or involved a commercial vehicle
- An uninsured or underinsured driver was involved
- Your claim is denied or significantly delayed
- The insurance company’s offer seems unreasonably low
- You’re feeling pressured or confused by the claims process
A skilled personal injury attorney serves as both your shield and advocate—protecting you from insurance company tactics while building the strongest possible case for maximum compensation.
The VIP Injury Attorneys Difference: Fighting When Others Won't
At VIP Injury Attorneys, we understand what’s at stake after an accident. Medical bills pile up, work becomes impossible, and the future feels uncertain. Insurance companies know this and often leverage your vulnerability to minimize your settlement.
Our approach is different. We stand in your corner, every step of the way. We understand the insurance industry’s tactics because we face them daily—and we know how to counter them effectively.
When you choose VIP Injury Attorneys, you’re not just hiring a law firm; you’re gaining a tireless advocate who:
- Handles all communication with insurance companies, shielding you from their tactics
- Gathers comprehensive evidence to build an irrefutable case
- Works with medical experts to document the full extent of your injuries
- Calculates the true value of your claim, including future impacts
- Negotiates aggressively for the maximum possible settlement
- Takes your case to trial when insurance companies refuse to offer fair compensation
Most importantly, we offer a “No Win, No Fee” guarantee. If we don’t recover compensation for you, you don’t pay us anything.
The Bottom Line: Protect Yourself After an Accident
When dealing with insurance companies after an accident, remember these key guidelines:
- Seek immediate medical attention—even for seemingly minor injuries
- Report the accident to your insurance company, but keep details minimal
- Never admit fault or apologize for the accident
- Avoid discussing your injuries or accepting early settlement offers
- Don’t speculate about facts you aren’t certain about
- Decline requests for recorded statements without legal counsel
- Contact an experienced personal injury attorney before making significant decisions
The right approach to insurance communication—and knowing when to bring in legal representation—can be the difference between struggling financially and receiving the full compensation you deserve.
Need Help After an Accident?
When injury strikes, life can turn upside down. Medical bills pile up, work becomes impossible, and the future feels uncertain. Don’t face this alone. VIP Injury Attorneys stand in your corner, every step of the way.
Let us help you fight for the treatment you need and the compensation you deserve. We offer a “No Win, No Fee” guarantee! So don’t settle for less than VIP treatment. Contact us today for a free consultation and let us take the fight off your shoulders. We’ll handle the legal battles while you focus on healing and rebuilding your life.
Stay updated on important legal and insurance changes by subscribing to our newsletter or following us on Facebook, YouTube, Instagram, and TikTok.